
Accommodation or Modification? The Fair Housing Difference Every Landlord Should Know
A landlord in Hughesville gets a note from a tenant: "I would like to install a grab bar in the bathroom." The landlord treats it like a request to repaint a wall and says no. That one answer could turn into a fair housing problem, because fair housing law treats two kinds of requests very differently.
Accommodation: A Change to a Rule or Policy
A reasonable accommodation is a change to a rule, policy or the way you do things so a person with a disability can use and enjoy the home. A common example is allowing an assistance animal in a building with a no-pets rule. Under the joint HUD and DOJ guidance, the housing provider generally covers the cost of an accommodation unless it creates an undue burden.
Modification: A Change to the Physical Space
A reasonable modification is a physical change to the home, like a grab bar, a ramp or a wider doorway. Under the same guidance, the tenant generally pays for a modification. A landlord cannot refuse a reasonable modification just because it changes the unit. A landlord also cannot raise the security deposit because a tenant asks for one.
Who Pays, in Plain Words
Policy change: the landlord generally pays, unless it is an undue burden. Physical change: the tenant generally pays. Before you answer a request, ask yourself one question. Is this a change to a rule, or a change to the building? That answer tells you which set of rules applies.
What About Move-Out?
For changes inside the unit, the landlord can ask the tenant to restore the space only if the change would make the unit worse for the next renter and only if the landlord asks. A grab bar that does not affect the next tenant usually does not need to be removed. Reasonable wear is a different matter from damage, so document the unit's condition at move-in and move-out.
What You Can and Cannot Ask
You cannot ask a tenant about the nature or severity of a disability. You may ask for verification only when the disability or the need for the request is not obvious. Keep the request and your answer in writing.
Common Questions
Can I say no because the change lowers resale value? The guidance says a reasonable modification generally cannot be refused just because it changes the unit. Talk to an attorney before you deny a request.
What if the request seems unreasonable? Do not just say no. Respond in writing, talk through options, and get legal advice before you deny.
Does this apply to every rental? Rules can differ by property type and by situation. Confirm with HUD, the Maryland Commission on Civil Rights or a Maryland attorney.
Before You Answer That Request
Got a request and not sure which kind it is? It starts with a conversation. We walk through how to sort it, what to put in writing and when to call an attorney. Start here: https://rental911.net/coaching
This is general information, not legal advice. Source: HUD and DOJ Joint Statement on Reasonable Modifications. Confirm current rules with HUD or a Maryland attorney.